Is the smell a gas leak or a water problem?
First, rule out gas. Natural gas has an added odor that smells like rotten eggs, so a leak is easy to notice. If the smell is in the air near a gas appliance, leave the home and call the gas utility from outside.
If the smell only shows up when hot water runs, and the air near the heater smells normal, the cause is in the water. That is the problem this guide covers, and it is one water heater repair for Winter Garden homes handles often.
What causes a rotten egg smell in hot water?
The smell is hydrogen sulfide gas. In a water heater, it usually forms when certain bacteria in the water react with the metal of the anode rod. The anode rod is a metal rod inside the tank that corrodes on purpose to protect the tank from rust. A warm tank that sits unused for days, such as after a trip, gives those bacteria time to grow.
- Hot water only smells: almost always the anode rod and bacteria in the tank.
- Hot and cold both smell: the source may be the water supply or the drain lines instead.
- One fixture only: often a drain trap or the fixture itself.
- After vacation: stagnant water in a warm tank.
How is a smelly water heater fixed?
| Fix | What it does |
|---|---|
| Flush the tank | Clears sediment where bacteria can live |
| Replace the anode rod | A different rod type can stop the reaction |
| Disinfect the tank | Kills bacteria inside the tank |
| Run hot water after trips | Clears stagnant water from the tank |
Our water heater maintenance visit includes a flush and an anode rod check, which solve most cases. Some owners in Belle Meade notice the smell after the home sits empty, and our page on water heater maintenance in Belle Meade covers what a visit there includes.
Can a water softener make the smell worse?
Sometimes. Softened water can change how quickly some anode rods react, which can increase the odor in certain tanks. If the smell started after a softener went in, tell us. A different anode rod made for softened water often fixes it while keeping the softener's benefits.
When should you call about the smell?
Call if the smell lasts more than a day or two after running the hot water, if it comes back after a flush, or if you also see rusty water. Those signs point to the anode rod or the tank itself. If the smell is in the air near the heater rather than in the water, leave and call the gas utility first.
Rotten egg smell FAQs
Is rotten egg smelling hot water safe to shower in?
At the low levels common in water heaters, it is usually a nuisance rather than a health risk. Still, have it fixed, and leave the home if the smell is in the air near a gas appliance.
Why does only my hot water smell?
The reaction happens inside the warm tank, usually at the anode rod. Cold water does not pass through the tank, so it stays odor-free.
Will flushing my tank stop the smell?
It often helps for a while. If the smell returns, the anode rod usually needs to be changed to a different type.
Do tankless water heaters get the smell?
Less often, because they do not store water or use an anode rod. If a tankless home has the smell, the source is likely elsewhere in the plumbing.