Water Heater Leaking? What to Do First in Winter Garden, FL

Finding water around your heater is stressful. A few quick steps, in the right order, stop most of the damage. Here is exactly what to do first.

The first ten minutes after you find a leak, in the right order. Written by the Grove Water Heaters team, updated 2026-11-19, about a 7-minute read.

  • Safety first
  • Stop the water
  • Find the source
A leaking water heater with four possible leak sources markedIllustration: a tank water heater in a drain pan with a puddle. Tags mark four leak sources in order: the top fittings, the relief valve and its line, the drain valve, and the tank body. 1 Top fittings 2 T&P valve 3 Drain valve 4 Tank body Find the source, then fix it top to bottom, in that order
Leaking Water Heater RepairWinter Garden, FL ยท ZIP 34787

What should you do the moment you see a leak?

  1. Check for gas. If you smell rotten eggs near a gas heater, leave the home and call the gas utility from outside. Do nothing else first.
  2. Stay safe around water. If water is near outlets, cords or the panel, do not stand in it. Turn off power at the main breaker if you can reach it safely.
  3. Turn off the heat. Switch off the heater's breaker, or turn the gas control knob to off.
  4. Close the cold supply. Turn the valve on the cold pipe above the heater. That stops new water from feeding the leak.
  5. Relieve pressure. Open a hot tap in a nearby sink.
  6. Protect your things. Move boxes and valuables, and put towels down.
  7. Take photos. They help us and any insurance claim.

Then call. When you reach our Winter Garden water heater repair crew, tell us what you see and where the water seems to come from.

How can you tell where the water is coming from?

Once the heater is off and the area is dry, look from the top down. Water runs downhill, so a leak up high can look like a leak at the base.

Common leak sources
Where you see waterLikely sourceUsually fixable?
On top, at the pipesLoose or worn connectors, a shut-off valveYes
At the relief-valve pipeHigh pressure or a worn relief valveYes
At the small valve near the bottomDrain valve not sealingYes
Behind an electric panel coverElement gasketUsually
From the tank body or seamsRusted-through tankNo, needs replacement
On the floor, heater dryAC condensate, softener or washer hoseNot the heater

What should you avoid doing?

  • Do not cap or plug the relief-valve pipe. It is a safety device, and blocking it is dangerous.
  • Do not drain a hot tank yourself. The water can scald, and old drain valves can break.
  • Do not turn the heat back on until the cause is fixed.
  • Do not ignore a small drip. Slow leaks grow and can damage walls and floors out of sight.

What happens when we come out for a leak?

We confirm the heater is safe, dry it off and watch for the first drop, starting at the top. We test the home's water pressure too, since high pressure is a common cause of relief valve leaks. Then we explain the source and give you a written price. Fittings, valves and gaskets are usually fixed in the same visit. A failed tank means a replacement.

Our leaking water heater repair service follows that order on every call. In Black Lake Park, homes were built about 2005 to 2008, and many second tanks there are near the age when leaks start. Our page on leaking water heater repair in Black Lake Park covers the sources we find most there.

How can you prevent the next leak?

A drain pan with a drain line, an expansion tank where the home needs one, a yearly flush and an anode rod check every few years do most of the work. A low-cost water leak alarm on the floor beside the heater adds an early warning, which matters most for heaters in closets or over finished floors.

Leaking water heater FAQs

Is a leaking water heater dangerous?

The water itself is the main risk to your home. It becomes a safety risk when water reaches electrical parts or when a gas heater has other problems. Shut off water and power or gas, then call.

Can I still use hot water if my heater is leaking?

It is best not to. Keep the cold supply off so the tank does not refill and feed the leak.

Why is there water under my heater but the tank looks dry?

The water may be from a nearby AC condensate line, a water softener or a washer hose. It may also be condensation on a gas tank when it first fires.

How fast should a leak be fixed?

A tank body leak should be handled right away. A slow drip from a fitting is less urgent but should still be fixed soon, before it damages the floor or walls.

Questions about your heater?

Stop it, then fix it

Call Grove Water Heaters and our local team will walk you through the shut-off and find the source.

(407) 555-0147
Water heater trouble?Winter Garden, FL · ZIP 34787Call (407) 555-0147